
|
|
spdracerut posted on November 11, 2011 00:00 
Tested: Fluke Thermal Imager
By Khiem Dinh
Heat, it's a quantity we have to deal with in motorsports yet we often don't have a clear picture of it. Thermal management is critical to performance and reliability of any race vehicle; everything from brake fluid temperatures, to rear differential temperatures, to making sure hot parts in the engine bay don’t melt other components. One tool that can be used in product development and race track setup is a thermal imager. I had access to a Fluke Ti32 thermal imager and put it to use.
Between working in different automotive jobs, I have also worked in HVAC (heating, ventilation, air-conditioning) and a little bit of aerospace. Thermal imagers are used extensively in HVAC and building restoration to ensure heat exchangers are working correctly and also for spotting water damage. Aerospace needs them to ensure all the components on their products work correctly and spot any thermal management issues. Cars, especially race cars with turbochargers, also have many heat exchangers and thermal management issues. So the commonality between applications got me to thinking about how to use a thermal imager in an automotive application.
Fluke has a whole line of thermal imagers ranging from budget (~$2000) and low temperature to high-end and higher temperature capability (~$9000+). I was interested in measuring very hot brake rotors and exhaust components, so a Ti32 fitted my needs. My first test was to use the Fluke Ti32 in a product development type of application.
Intercoolers on turbocharged cars are important to getting maximum power out of an engine. However, in the automotive aftermarket setting, I can tell you that almost no product development is done on intercooler design beyond making the intercooler fit and not having leaks. What I mean by this is that little attention is paid towards flow distribution within the intercooler core to maximize efficiency. I would even venture to say that many OEMs spend little time in optimizing intercooler designs, though often times, the OEM engineers have their hands tied with regards to packaging constraints, cost considerations, manufacturing considerations, deadlines, etc.
 |
| A shot of a front mount intercooler during a dyno run. In this picture, you can see there is some gradient from top to bottom. The hot air from the turbo is entering from the left and exiting the intercooler on the right. |
Here's a short video of the intercooler heating up during a dyno pull. Don't pay too much attention to the absolute values of the temperatures measured as I did not have the emissivity setting correct for the aluminum finish of the intercooler.
My next test was checking brake rotor temperatures. If you recall from my last track day in Project S2000, the rear rotors were significantly hotter than the fronts using the good ole hand pyrometer. Now that I had a tool at measure actual temperatures, I went to my closed test course and performed a test. My test procedure was simple consisting of an out and back loop. From a stop, I would go full throttle to the top of second gear and then stand on the brakes. I then did a U-turn and again went full throttle to the top of second gear and performed a hard stop where I had an assistant use the thermal imager to measure the rotor temperatures. I performed this loop about 10 times.
Friday, November 11, 2011 12:59 AM
here's a little fun I had with one I barrowed from work http://youtu.be/AYBuJ9Sf3bo
Friday, November 11, 2011 9:15 AM
I can assure that OEMs do significant testing on all of their engine components. While they are definitely held back with cost and packaging restraints, they test the **** out of their engine components. Have you ever seen what 35 temperature probes in a single catalyst brick looks like? I have, and that's just a test that is run for cold start catalyst temperature distribution.

Friday, November 11, 2011 10:10 AM
While I haven't seen what 35 thermocouples look like in a catalyst brick, I have seen a very extensive CFD analysis on a SCR brick to optimize flow, improve light-off, and improve urea distribution to minimize emissions. Optimization of emissions related components has become critical with super strict regulations, especially cold start up. There are a few and varied interesting engine control strategies being used even beyond just component design. I did spend a summer as an intern at a major automotive company in their durability testing facility. Now working for a supplier, we do our own torture testing. However, there's a difference between performance testing and durabilty testing. Usually, some minimum performance target is determined and if everything works well enough then no optimization is needed. From my experience, moreso 5-10 years ago, things like heat exchangers, exhaust manifolds, and intake manifolds received little attention. Have you seen an exhaust manifold on a 2000 Ford Expedition with a V8? It's an absolute piece of junk performance wise! It's about the same size as a camshaft, I kid you not. With the inclusion of faster and easier CFD systems into the design process (allowed by more modern computers), it is being used more commonly now. However, time is still a major constraint. For example, the 2012 Nissan GTR received refinements to its aero package that improved performance. Why weren't these on the previous generation? They didn't have the time to do it.
Friday, November 11, 2011 10:27 AM
For the weld photo, is it possible that the heat retention properties of the weld material vs. the header tube material could have something to do with the temperature readings? Or possibly that there is an air flow restriction at the joint which is causing an increase in temperature? Perhaps a stall in the airflow at the joint or the gap between the pipe sections? The intercooler video is neat. I'd love to see a video of the heak soak on the factory top mount intercooler of a tuned turbo Subaru on a dyno. I'll bet it's pretty interesting.
Friday, November 11, 2011 10:44 AM
We have customers utilizing our data/video sync with thermal imaging cameras on tires. Although we have 8 spot arrays that will tell you the tire story, a video CAN synced with data in the distance based plot helps out a lot. thanks for this. I seem to recall seeing thermal cameras for a little cheaper than that.
Friday, November 11, 2011 11:02 AM
Very interesting, we were actually talking yesterday about getting one of these for our company, but for a different application (data centers).
Friday, November 11, 2011 12:59 PM
Mark, are those 8 spot arrays for tire temperatures resonably priced? do you have any further info on them?
Friday, November 11, 2011 2:06 PM
I've seen this movie. Predator, right? :) Khiem - This is an extremely cool DAQ tool! It's nice to see a more thorough analysis of a Project S2000. I like those hood vents that help to keep water out while still venting. I was thinking along the same lines as ErikO, material and/or minor air flow stagnation inside the header itself.
Friday, November 11, 2011 2:17 PM
San Diegans can borrow a thermal camera for free from the library at the Energy Resource Center: http://energycenter.org/index.php/outreach-a-education/san-diego-energy-resource-center/resource-and-tool-library Just tell them you're working on making your car more efficient...
Sunday, November 20, 2011 7:00 PM
Does the fact that back brakes were hotter than you thought (hot as the front) make for a case to upgrade the brakes to a large rotor? speaking of brakes: what is the deal with no emergency brake on Stoptech and others for the rear, like it is not that complicated(is it???). How about rears for the S2K from another Honda product? Third the heat signature on the hood is obviously the radiator. Assume car was stopped for sometime, what would it have looked like moving?
Sunday, November 20, 2011 11:38 PM
Racing Brake makes a rear rotor upgrade that uses the stock caliper I believe and retains the parking brake which is integrated with the stock caliper. I'm just weary of it as the bigger rotor should screw up the brake bias. It's an option if I figure out a way to put in a proportioning valve, but I'm not really worried about it for now. I'd rather just work on the cooling aspect which should be pretty simple. The heat sig is from the radiator. Notice the rear part of the hood is still warm. Have to also take into account that most of the hood has insulation on it. Locating vents aft of the radiator is a good bet regardless. Check out the hood vent on the Mustang GT500 :)
Sunday, November 20, 2011 11:39 PM
Oh yeah, I tried to check the hood while moving for a little bit, but it wasn't that safe.
Monday, November 21, 2011 9:01 PM
Help me out here as I am still playing the newbie card as long as I can! Can you briefly explain how you can greatly multiply the stopping power of the front brakes without regard to brake bias(at least I do not think you mentioned it) yet improving the rears will screw it up.
Monday, November 21, 2011 9:33 PM
Sure. StopTech sizes their pistons and whatnot to maintain a proper brake bias in working with the stock system. Under 'Industry Partners', click on StopTech and you can read all about it :)
 
|
|
MotoIQ Proudly Presents Our Partners:
|