
|
|
Mike Kojima posted on June 22, 2010 18:49 

Sierra Sierra
Rays has involved excellence in engineering as well. Most of Rays engineers are also engaged enthusiasts who have a clue, not your typical corporate drones. State of the art modeling techniques such as Finite Element stress Analysis commonly known as FEA are used to optimize design, giving the best strength and stiffness for the lowest weight. FEA allows the engineers to pair weight to a minimum and make stronger more durable wheels by being able to predict stress concentrations within the structure of the wheel when load is applied. FEA is integrated into the CAD (Computer Aided Design) drafting system and the engineers can use this data to quickly change the design and verify what each change can do to the strength, weight and durability of a wheel before the first prototype part is made.
 |
 |
| Rays makes extensive use of FEA or Finite Element Analysis to optimize the design of their wheels. Areas of high stress are warmer in color and cooler colored areas are sections with lower stress. The engineers experiment with the design of the wheels to eliminate hot spots. This way the lightest and strongest wheel can be designed. Of course the engineer has to be experienced with wheel design so the forces can be inputted correctly and Rays engineers have plenty of experience. |
Rays wheels for both OEM and aftermarket applications are built to exacting JWL standards. JWL is a standard of the Japanese government where a wheel must pass a brace of grueling durability tests to be legal for street use. The wheels must pass tests for rotary and radial fatigue, a strenuous test where a wheel with a tire is loaded with a heavy weight to simulate a car's weight then run at a heavy side and up and down cyclical load for a required number of cycles. Then the same wheel if it passes is subjected to a 13 and 90 degree impact test where it is hit with a calibrated hydraulically driven pendulum. The wheels must not deform excessively, crack, debead the tire or lose air pressure. As further proof, Rays has their own internal standard JWL+R where their wheels must exceed the JWL tests by 100% even for their lightest wheels. Ever wonder what sort of testing is done on Volk knockoffs? Probably none with a fake JWL stamp.
 |
| A fatigue tester machine puts a load on a wheel tire assembly and rotates it through cycles. |
After this proof testing Rays does further validation with salt spray, compound accelerated corrosion, paint adhesion and UV degradation testing to ensure the wheel will last under the harshest road conditions.


Wednesday, June 23, 2010 12:46 AM
Awesome article! What do you think of the strength of Enkei RPF1 wheels? Would you recommend them for track use and are they comparable in strength to Volks?
Wednesday, June 23, 2010 12:51 AM
They are decently strong and a good wheel, perhaps the best of the cast wheels, they are not a good as the Volks of course but they are cheaper. Personally I only use Volks but if I was on a tighter budget I would not have a problem with them at all.
Wednesday, June 23, 2010 3:49 AM
Wow. That CNC machine is dimensionally accurate to within one thousandths of a mm. That is impressive. I wonder how they achieve such a tolerance.
Wednesday, June 23, 2010 9:03 AM
It's normal for a top line CNC machine nowdays.
Wednesday, June 23, 2010 9:31 AM
A lot of people say that when you buy a name brand part you're just paying for the name. In another forum I mentioned that all big names come from somewhere and if their products were not top-notch, they would never have made it to the top to begin with. This is proof positive why Volks are at the top. Our SAE team was considering a set of Volks for our car 2 years ago. We went with Kaiser instead. They have been good, but they have bent. The Volks obviously wouldn't have and perhaps next year we will finally get the budget to upgrade.
Wednesday, June 23, 2010 1:10 PM
Buying fake Volks makes absolutely no sense to me. You get 95-100% of the shitty looks and 0% of the excellent manufacturing process and superior engineering. It's a lose-lose situation! =D
Wednesday, June 23, 2010 2:28 PM
Great article...I loved my old TE37's. I am trying my hardest to not go the cheaper route with RPF1's on my FD track car...I would love a set of CE28N's. BenFenner, since when do Volks look shitty?
Wednesday, June 23, 2010 2:32 PM
This article is awesome. I drive a lot of 4x4 stuff, so its a lot easier to understand why driving a large tire and heavy wheel on the streets is tiresome.
Wednesday, June 23, 2010 5:18 PM
Aren't you worried about getting your $3000-4000 wheels stolen? After price, this is the next thing I worry about.
Thursday, June 24, 2010 1:59 PM
Great article Mike. Never knew how much work went into them. Now I know why they cost that much. I was just curious. Roughly how much is a top line CNC machine? # until240 I took the Volk & Rays stickers off my TE37s because I thought they looked better without them and I also didn't want to attract that kind of attention. I worry too sometimes. Without the stickers, I hope people think I'm rolling RAVS VORKS. Isn't that the exact opposite of a girl buying a fake LV purse. Ha ha ha.
Thursday, June 24, 2010 3:33 PM
Just buy 4 sets of wheel locks, 4 locks for each wheel :P
Thursday, June 24, 2010 7:15 PM
Perfect article!! I want more of this kind of tech
Thursday, June 24, 2010 10:26 PM
Want more of this kind of tech? Make sure you spread the link to this story to your friends via email, facebook, and forums you frequent. The only way Mike and staff are going to be able to continue writing cool shit like this is if there are visitors and of course, advertisers.
Thursday, June 24, 2010 11:38 PM
Jim, maybe you could go onto Ebay and buy some sick RAV VORKS stickers to throw off some potential thieves and for that *bling* look... =P Crazy the amount of work that goes into forging a wheel. It's amazing that they can nearly complete a wheel by hitting it a couple times. =) Oh and maybe it's just me, but I'm not used to reading about RPF1's being cheap. Then again, I haven't really shopped for non-OEM wheels, so what do I know? Though there was the guy on craigslist who was selling steelies w/wheel covers for $600.....
Friday, June 25, 2010 9:53 AM
#Jim That's actually a good idea. And I suppose that's what insurance is for. #speedball3 Cheap is relative. Volks are about $600+ per wheel, RPF1's are about $350 a wheel, Rotas are about $250 per wheel. This is assuming 18" wheels.
Friday, June 25, 2010 10:19 AM
# speedball3# & until240, I agree and like both your comments. I should just paint some red Chinese dragons over them and get it over with. Ha ha ha! = )
Friday, June 25, 2010 10:47 AM
Eric, going off your idea, shouldn't Motoiq set up a facebook page for people to "Like," or set up accounts on other community sites too. A lot of stars do it. It's not something you really have to keep up with but just a sign post to direct friends of friends of friends to check out your site. Sometimes I check out my friends "Likes" on facebook just for curiosity sake. Might help to get the word out.
Friday, June 25, 2010 5:33 PM
Excellent article [as always]! Very informative, I even linked to this article from our local forums [like w/ all my favorites]. I'm pretty sure that's supposed to be .001" [inch]. MM's are broken down to tenths when dealing w/ machining process and tools. l--------------l ~1" l-l ~2mm Our HAAS CNC machines at work are pretty new and CAN get to within .0005 on a very slow run.
Friday, June 25, 2010 10:11 PM
Mike, can you explain Enkei's MAT process and SSR's semi solid forge process also. thanks!!
Saturday, June 26, 2010 12:20 AM
Jimbo: good call on the "like" action. I think there's a giant list of stuff that the site guys have on their to do list, but a great idea. Mike, Frank, Jeff what do you guys think? ProTree: Enkei MAT = fancy way to describe pressure casting. I mean c'mon, MAT stands for Most Advanced Technology. I'm sorry, but that is lame sounding. While it is probably an advanced casting procedure, it is still cast. You can read about SSR's SSF process here, but keep in mind that its a virtual sales brochure: Tire Rack. I like Volks, but I've always liked SSRs too.
Saturday, June 26, 2010 4:09 AM
We do have a Facebook page, its our top referral. http://www.facebook.com/#!/pages/MotoIQcom/90592438730?ref=ts MAT is a cast wheel with a roll formed rim section. It's much better than a conventional cast wheel but not as good as forged, especially not like the Rays 3D forging method. SSF is also called squeeze casting, the wheel is cast and when it is still mushy, not fully solidified, the mold squeezes the wheel into its final shape. This is way better than casting but not close to the Rays forging method. Top CNC machines can get to within 0.0001 nowdays, what used to be grinding tolerance.
Saturday, June 26, 2010 10:34 AM
My bad. I guess I was searching under friends in Facebook, and the right column gets cut off even when I fully expand the page on my laptop so I never noticed the Facebook icon.
Sunday, June 27, 2010 6:31 AM
I stand corrected.. That is very impressive that they build a wheel to that close of a spec. Helps explain the $600+ per wheel price tag as well.
Monday, June 28, 2010 12:49 PM
M-P, we could get into an in-depth artistic discussion about why Volks look bad but I'm sure I wouldn't change your opinion on the matter, so I'll spare everyone the diatribe. Obviously that is my opinion, and looks are always subjective. I just have a very solid opinion of what makes a good looking wheel, and what doesn't. Almost all Rays wheels look bad to me for very specific reasons. I'm sure almost everyone else disagrees. No big deal. =)
Tuesday, June 29, 2010 8:53 PM
Thanks for the story Mike, its always interesting to study those companies who work their craft rather than just manufacture parts.
Wednesday, June 30, 2010 11:05 PM
How do you guys feel about Yokohama Advan wheels?
Wednesday, June 30, 2010 11:12 PM
RAYS makes Advan wheels.
Saturday, July 03, 2010 1:53 PM
really? i didn't know rays made cast wheels.
Saturday, July 03, 2010 2:31 PM
Some of Rays non Volk wheels like some Gram Lites and some Avan are cast.
 
|
|
MotoIQ Proudly Presents Our Partners:
|