
|
|
Annie Sam posted on March 01, 2010 22:58 

Nissan Titan Large Capacity Oil Pan, Cure for Transmission Overheating?
By Annie Sam
If you are an avid MotoIQ reader you will have read how transmission heating problems while towing in my Nissan Titan has lead our editor to purchase a Toyota Tundra. When Nissan first introduced the Titan, it was a half ton truck like no other with performance and towing capacity that were best in class by a long shot. In fact it was the Titan that triggered a war in performance in the half ton truck category among the manufacturers that the Tundra is currently winning. No matter, the Titan is still a good truck, especially if its major weaknesses can be fixed.
 |
| Getting stuck on the side of the road in the middle of summer on the Baker grade while trying to get to a race gets old real fast. |
Without forcing you to read about our Nissan Titan's transmission woes, basically the trucks major problem is that the transmission temperatures get very high when towing going up long steep grades such as the notorious Baker grade and the Grapevine, especially in the summer time. We have experienced this even though our Titan has the factory tow package which has two oil coolers, one in the radiator and an oil to air unit in the front of the truck. Since we have to climb over the Grapevine to get to Buttonwillow where we race frequently, this is quite an issue. We have been forced to stop several times to let the tranny cool as to not damage it. When it’s hot in the summer and you are tired and want to go home or are eager to get to the track, this sucks.
 |
| The added volume of the PWL oil pan on the left is obvious when compared to the stock pan on the right. |
Strangely we have noticed a puzzling phenomenon, it helps if you go faster up the hill; we have noticed that the transmission temps drop significantly if you maintain 70 mph. This is not always possible as you often don’t have the power to go up steep grades this fast, not to mention that it's 15 mph over the California towing speed limit. We also noticed lower transmission temps when we manually down shifted into lower gear and revved the engine higher instead of leaving the transmission in drive. This indicates that something must be slipping when the transmission is left in drive although no obvious slipping can be felt. It’s not the best thing for the engine or for fuel economy though.
We also didn’t seem to overheat the transmission in the first 30K miles that we had the truck, although our heaviest towing in hot weather was after this point. Note that we never tow anywhere near the truck's 9000 lb capacity, our average towing weight is usually under 5000 lbs.
 |
| This is what the OEM countermeasure finned diff cover looks like. Nissan used this when fixing Titans with warranty claims and it came on all Titans after the second year of production. If your diff cover looks smooth and you tow, you had better get one of these or one of the good aftermarket higher capacity units or you will be sorry! |
We are not alone in our problems. The Titan is notorious for overheating its tranny and rearend, especially when towing near its maximum capacity. So what to do? Our Titan has the later Nissan countermeasure differential cover which is an alloy piece with fins and a slightly larger capacity. It is imperative that you use a premium oil for the Nissan differential as it runs hot and the factory fill is high quality synthetic gear oil. We replaced the 60,000 mile old OEM fluid with 2 liters of Royal Purple synthetic gear oil in the 75W140 weight as recommended by Nissan. If you feel that you need more oil cooling or capacity, PML makes a diff cover with .75 quarts more capacity, Stillen makes a part with 7/8 quart more capacity and Mag Hytec makes a cover that holds a whopping 3.75 quarts more than stock and comes with a dip stick. If your Titan comes with an old style unfinned cover, and you tow, you need to invest in the finned cover or one of these aftermarket parts.
 |
| We used Royal Purple gear oils and Amsoil ATF for this project. |
Tuesday, March 02, 2010 5:23 AM
Interesting story, I've always liked the Titans but it seemed like the Tundra would always steal their thunder. Hopefully these modifications will help keep those temps down. If you guys ever feel like gettin' real crazy why not tap that rear diff cover and plumb in an oil pump and cooler :)
Tuesday, March 02, 2010 6:58 AM
It sounds like alot of your excessive heat problems are coming from towing in D5 instead of D4. I tow my racecar with an Armada and have noticed similar phenomena in the past. In my experience, towing in D5 is OK as long as the torque converter can stay locked, but when it unlocks and slips, the shearing of the fluid in the torque converter causes the ATF temps to go thru the roof quickly. The extra engine speed in 4th gear is enough to keep the torque converter locked and avoid this problem. I don't have my owner's manual in front of me, but I believe it says to tow in D4 mode. Here is a link to a relevant [although not all encompassing, just what I could find quickly] thread on TitanTalk.com about the topic: http://www.titantalk.com/forums/titan-towing-hauling/38568-towing-d-versus-4th-gear-w-tow-mode.html For $200 it's probably not a bad investment, but I could find a better place for that money on my racecar :-)
Tuesday, March 02, 2010 8:14 AM
$200 isnt bad, not if you have ever been stuck on the side of the road. Nissan messed up on this truck, put stuff not rated for the power and claimed tow capacity on it. These is no way I would tow 9000 lbs with a Titian. I have friends that tired to tow big enclosed trailers and had there rear end glow red hot! Tow mode should take care of transmission scheduling issues like torque converter lock up. Nissan just didn't test this truck enough before releasing it. I am not sure if the torque converter can stay locked when towing, it is just a thin band of cardboard like friction material, it would probably burn up easily. Usually tow mode unlocks the toque converter.

Tuesday, March 02, 2010 9:38 AM
The rear end is definitely a weak point as well as lack of testing, which is suprising because that is my job at a competing automaker. We regularly test fully loaded on the same grades mentioned in the article. Sounds like we are doing a good job using customer oriented courses... The Armada was released a year after the Titan I think? And with the IRS I have never had an issue and have heard many tales of people towing tall motorhomes at max capacity in the summer over Grapevine. I disagree on torque converter control though. From what I've read, Tow Mode just changes the 1->2 and 2->3 shift mapping. During flat road towing, there really isn't much load so lockup is feasible if not feedback control with small amounts of slip. But if you're talking about climbing grades, then yes, it will slip the t/c significantly creating lots of heat that the extra engine speed and thus transmission oil pump speed allow more flow for better cooling in 4th gear rather than 5th.
Tuesday, March 02, 2010 9:55 AM
I know on our F250 tow mode unlocks the converter, you can feel it. The Armada uses the Nissan R230 diff which is stronger than rocks. The Titian uses the Dana 44 which is underrated for this app. I think this is the same diff in the old F Body Camaros. The odd thing is that Nissan Tests on the Baker Grade and the Grapevine. They were testing with a big heavy toy box, yet I know racers that experience the glowing rear ends, overheating trannies and warping brakes, in fact every person i know that tows with a Titan usually experiences two out of three of these and some experiance all three. Later Titan's have bigger brakes and the finned alloy rear diff cover which helps alot. It took Nissan years to fix these issues correctly. I think the trannies still overheat. The Titan was a ground breaking truck but Nissan didn't attack its problems aggressively enough and perhaps released early without enough testing.
Tuesday, March 02, 2010 10:16 PM
thats what feeds the heavy aftermarket for Nissans. They do a great job out of the box, and I am convinced that they under-engineer some components as to give their motorsports department something to work on and cut down on pricing. Kind of a big brother looking out for his younger sibling effect. Imagine if everything that Nissan,Honda, Toyota etc. made was perfect from the get go. That would make them overpriced from the showroom floor and make the aftermarket that much more exclusive, taking the pricing and accessability away from a strong consumer range. Essentially they would become like Mercedes/AMG or BMW/M Division. Wonderful cars and development but not accessible to everyone.

Wednesday, March 03, 2010 1:41 PM
From my experience with diesel Chevys and my CTD Dodge, tow/haul makes for more aggressive converter lockup. Putting my Dodge in "2" with the tow/haul button pushed means it locks up at 30mph instead of 40mph. Same thing I've noticed with Allisons. Either way, the key to managing transmission temperature when towing with an automatic is managing converter lockup. If the converter is unlocked, you're making huge amounts of heat. Either drop down a gear, or get out of the accelerator (or both) until it locks back up. I'd rather crawl up a grade at 45mph than nuke an automatic trans. BTW, to tell if your converter is locked up, just let off the accelerator and get back on it. If the rpms follow your foot in a linear fashion, the converter is unlocked. Dick with the gears/accelerator until it locks up. Keep in mind that you can overheat a trans going downhill as well. Mike, I agree, the D44 that comes in the Titans is WAY too small. Previous D44 rear axle applications include such towing beasts as the Izuzu Rodeo, XJ Cherokees and the newer Wranglers. Everyone else only trusts it on the front end. Looking under a Titan, the pumpkin is just laughingly small. I'm pretty sure that F-bodies came with GM's 12 bolt though.
Wednesday, March 03, 2010 2:11 PM
BTW, did you guys look into a larger cooler?
 
|
|
MotoIQ Proudly Presents Our Partners:
|