Krash
 MotoIQ Newb Send PM Posts:6

 |
| 01-25-2011 01:06 PM |
|
Im not exactly too informed on much when it comes to cars besides your typical slightly above average knowledge and suspension comes off as a new language. Ive been having the hardest time trying to find a set or even brand of coilovers that are in a reasonable price range.I also have been looking for over a month now and i really dont want to spent money on something i will regret. Im aware of the repudable names like stance and KTS etc., but my pockets arent that deep. Im looking to spend around $800-$900, yet have not had any luck on my side.
If anyone could point me in the right direction or possibly give me some advice it would be of great help. I drive a 92' s13 coupe, and plan to use daily and occasionally track it when the oppurtunity presents itself. I also plan to buy other suspension related parts farther down the road.
thanks,
Krash
P.S. - Sorry if theres a post about this somewhere else, if there is a link to it should be fine. |
|
|
|
|
smartbomb
 MotoIQ Super Genius Send PM Posts:1904

 |
| 01-25-2011 06:54 PM |
|
Basicaly you get what you pay for. Stance is a knock off brand. I don't know about KTS other than they use good springs. |
|
|
|
|
Krash
 MotoIQ Newb Send PM Posts:6

 |
| 01-25-2011 09:28 PM |
|
I understand that fully, but any names you might know of that i could possibly take into consideration. i have no idea where to even start if thats what your saying. |
|
|
|
|
TonyCambio
 MotoIQ Newb Send PM Posts:62

 |
| 01-26-2011 04:58 AM |
|
Honestly, I wouldn't spend $800 on a set of coilovers - unless it was just for looks.
A lot of people use coilovers because they give a lot of drop & that's not necessarily a priority for a performance driver, or a racer.
Personally, I use Koni dampers for my street car/race car. If I decide to go with adjustable height, i will use Ground Control coils w/adjusters.
The last time I did suspension work on my car, I wouldn't buy anything that didn't have race credibility. That costs money & you'll be glad you spent the money up front, over buying sub-standard parts, realizing they're sub-standard, then buying better parts. |
|
|
|
|
smartbomb
 MotoIQ Super Genius Send PM Posts:1904

 |
| 01-26-2011 05:16 AM |
|
Coilover are important, the only time you wouuld not use them is if you could not due to rules for the class you are racing in. Street performance springs are too low and too soft. They suck. |
|
|
|
|
Fly'n_Z
 MotoIQ Staff Send PM Posts:154

 |
| 01-26-2011 06:32 AM |
|
From your other posts I believe you have a 92 S13 correct? If that's the case then the KTS coilovers might be an OK buy. Do not get the low or ultralow versions as that's unnecessary ghey extra lowering won't help your car handle. The KTS units might even fall a little outside your $800 budget but I cannot honestly recommend a set of coilovers at the $800 range that work well. Talk to Kuah at http://www.splparts.com / kuah@splparts.com and see what he suggests. Kuah is amazing and also sells many adjustable suspension components used in the S13 community. |
|
|
|
|
Big J
 MotoIQ Engineer Send PM Posts:559

 |
| 01-26-2011 08:16 AM |
|
We run BC on our track cars. |
|
|
|
|
BoxedFox
 MotoIQ ASE Certified Send PM Posts:255
 New Jersey
 |
| 01-26-2011 04:41 PM |
|
While $800 is not a lot of money, it is possible to get a reasonably decent coilover setup for that money. What I like to do is to buy servicable, blown dampers from people and send them in to be rebuilt and revalved. Not only does it come out cheaper, but I can have them valved to whatever specifications I want with whatever spring rates I need. You just need to do some research beforehand and make sure that you find a manufacturer that can do the rebuilds for a reasonable cost. My current favorate donor dampers are the current-gen Tein twin tubes (Basic, SS, Flex) and street monotubes (Mono-Flex). They're durable, plentiful, and people practically give them away once they're worn out. Also helps that the engineers at the west coast facility have been really good these last few years I've had work done. |
|
|
|
|
smartbomb
 MotoIQ Super Genius Send PM Posts:1904

 |
| 01-26-2011 07:51 PM |
|
Boxed Fox, what in your experiance are good cheap coilovers? All the ones I have tried to dial in for friends have been nearly useless so I don't even mess with them. I would like to figure out which ones are ok so I could reply to these sorts of questions. I like Tein as a lower cost suspension but to many people, this is expensive stuff. |
|
|
|
|
Big J
 MotoIQ Engineer Send PM Posts:559

 |
| 01-27-2011 03:13 AM |
|
I want to say BC are rebuildable with Bilstein valves because they use 46mm pistons like Bilstein does. If you need a setl a set that isn't off the shelf due to a spring rate change, the set will ship from the factory built to order with the spring rate and valving done per order, for the exact same price as an off the shelf set. WHich helps if you are on a budget and need a little more. But, you're going to be closer to the $1000 range. We haven't dyno'd the coilovers because we're still shaving lap times in other areas We had good results on the track with a Koni and GC combo too... but we blew the dampers and if you start running real spring rates you're going to need a re-valve.
|
|
|
|
|
BoxedFox
 MotoIQ ASE Certified Send PM Posts:255
 New Jersey
 |
| 01-27-2011 04:13 AM |
|
Posted By Mike Kojima on 01-26-2011 09:51 PM
Boxed Fox, what in your experiance are good cheap coilovers? All the ones I have tried to dial in for friends have been nearly useless so I don't even mess with them. I would like to figure out which ones are ok so I could reply to these sorts of questions. I like Tein as a lower cost suspension but to many people, this is expensive stuff.
Hmm... That's a tough one.
From my experience, I would say PIC Performance non-adjustables, Progress suspension's coilovers, and Bilstein Sport / HDs + coilover sleeves. I like PIC and Progress because their hardware is sturdy and they have engineers that seem to know what they're doing when it comes to reavalves to spec. The Bilsteins I like because they're so easy to play with. The parts are readily available, and they're so generic dimensionally that you can use stuff from other shocks. I haven't tried it myself but I know a few people who have Bilstein Sports with Ohlins pistons or AL-KO bits inside. That and because they're so easy to take apart, there are a lot of independent tuners (autocrossers, mostly) who service Bilstein shocks.
I'm still partial to non-adjustables, because I haven't really found too many sub-$1200 dampers where the adjusters work well. Even the new designs seem to suffer from "classic giant needle valve controlling a big bypass that shuts all the way at full hard" behavior. Only exception I can think of are the KYB built Tanabe adjustables, but I don't think they're servicable. In most cases I try to get the service center to do most of the tuning internally and just use the adjusters when it rains. |
|
|
|
|
yo vanilla
 MotoIQ Grease Monkey Send PM Posts:317
 Appleton, WI
 |
| 01-27-2011 06:54 AM |
|
There has to be SOME affordable, good options on the market. Keeping in mind of course that 9 of 10 aftermarket parts aren't so good at any rate, I will always have a hard time believing the ONLY way towards improvement is by spending thousands of dollars. Sounds like a budget comparison should be done, keep in mind the performance-minded buyer in this price point can't let perfect get in the way of good enough. Mike K, I know you like the KW's, do you have experience with other euro brands like Bilstein? |
|
|
|
|
BoxedFox
 MotoIQ ASE Certified Send PM Posts:255
 New Jersey
 |
| 01-27-2011 09:46 AM |
|
Posted By yo vanilla on 01-27-2011 08:54 AM
There has to be SOME affordable, good options on the market. Keeping in mind of course that 9 of 10 aftermarket parts aren't so good at any rate, I will always have a hard time believing the ONLY way towards improvement is by spending thousands of dollars. Sounds like a budget comparison should be done, keep in mind the performance-minded buyer in this price point can't let perfect get in the way of good enough.
Mike K, I know you like the KW's, do you have experience with other euro brands like Bilstein?
My biggest issue with the $700 ~ $1200 /kit dampers out there are the adjusters and the service.
Good adjusters are expensive to make. Even the big name brand dampers have adjuster issues. Take the ubiquitous Koni Yellows, for example. From an end-user standpoint, I hate their "infinitely adjustable" knob because the adjuster slips over time and you can never get the same setting twice. Internally, with the way they designed their rebound-only adjuster, it causes a ton of consistency issues between damper to damper. And because they had to make a simple design that they can mass produce, there's a lot of cross-talk as you get closer to full hard and full soft. For that much, I'd rather have combined compression and rebound with 6~12 detents.
Not to say that the single, combined adjustment dampers are all perfect either. With a lot of the single adjustable monotubes, they make the thread pitch so fine that a single click of the adjuster doesn't do anything (like all those coilover kits that advertise 30 clicks of adjustment). With some manufacturers, they build them so setting them to full stiff basically closes off the bypass. I can see how it makes sense from a manufacturing standpoint, but it also means that if your dampers are set up properly, you can't use the full stiff setting without having the things generate enormous amounts of low speed damping force, jack the hysteresis all to hell, and overpressurize the seals. Then on the other side of the spectrum you have dampers with 4 clicks where using the lower two cause the damper to stop damping (Bilstein PSS9). All part of the reason that I tend to gravitate towards non-adjustables for budget applications.
Servicability is important too. I only buy coilovers if the manufacturer, or a third party tuner, is able to service the dampers. At the very least, they need to be able to offer rebuilds and revalving for different spring rates. I won't buy coilovers from companies like Cusco, for example, because their idea of an overhaul is to send you a new damper cartridge from a box in one of their warehouses. What Big J mentioned about BC being able to have dampers valved to spec before they ship out is a big plus. There aren't too many companies out there that offer that kind of service for street coilovers, especially not for free.
Being able to service the damper is key, because that's sometimes all it takes to make a cheapo street coilover "good enough" for track use. A lot of the current gen "JDM" coilover kits actually use pretty decent hardware internally. They just happen to come set up wonky with spring rates that aren't condusive to track use. All they need is a different set of springs and a base revalve, and they'll easily match the guys running Koni 8611 based kits (especially since a lot of the 8611 users never seem to get their dampers revalved). |
|
|
|
|
Doctor Bruce
 MotoIQ Master Send PM Posts:134

 |
| 01-27-2011 01:35 PM |
|
I kind of posed this question to Mike a few days ago in one of the articles (project G35) and he's said the same thing twice now, which is the same thing my father mechanic of 40 years and shop owner of 30 years has told me countless times that sometimes, "you get what you pay for." Krash, if you could perhaps provide a baseline of performance you're hoping to get with these occasional track days. Maybe you should spend your money on some adjustable sway bars to tighten things up before finding the right coilover that will work for you. A quick search shows that site sponsors Whiteline and ST Suspensions have s13 sway bars (whiteline's is 2 point adjustable). Another option is along the same line as Boxedfox in trying to find a good used set on the forums, maybe zilvia.net? I know that Mike and many in the business feel that KW is one of the Gold Standard suspensions to look for, so maybe a used set of V2 or V3s might pop up in your price range. |
|
|
|
|
Krash
 MotoIQ Newb Send PM Posts:6

 |
| 01-27-2011 07:48 PM |
|
Geese, thats alot to take in. In all seriousness id haft to say the things you all have discussed is slightly out of my knowledge. I honestly am having a hard time in considering what in particular to respond to. i feel like i have no idea what a car is at this point. On the other hand, what i want exactly is performance one better than stock obviously i do not just want my car "slamed" thats ignorant. Im not the type of person to go out and just abuse my car like most others i appreciate what i have on account of me not being the most well off person. so these will actually possibly make me the happiest person ever when i manage to get them. I also plan to buy whitelines sway bars its funny that was mentioned. as far as dampers go, valving, spring rates, etc. i wouldn know what was any better. Im also currently a member of zilvia and check it almost religiously for parts i recently bought my exhaust from there. The price range can also bend a little im just not wanting to go over $1000 at check out. From personal experience and friends mistakes used parts isnt the way i would want to go unless it was from a person that has similar views on cars. In short, I feel like everyone that responded did so in a different language. like i said before im not too knowledgeable in this department. Great advice ive taken from these response that a months research is not even close to the amount of time needed to find a good, well priced set. If theres another way other than coilovers that could deliver the same result id gladly take that into consideration. Geese, this is intense. |
|
|
|
|
Krash
 MotoIQ Newb Send PM Posts:6

 |
| 01-27-2011 08:47 PM |
|
Reread it, makes a little more sense that way. Boxed Fox would you be any interested in maybe finding this newly found possibility for me? as far as adjustable coils go i guess i could deal without and just have adjustable sway-bars. that sounds a lil more plausible to me possibly even cheaper. Nutshell: dampers, springs, adjustable sway-bars, and adjustable end-links. what would be the outcome of this? would this idea be a more suitable one for me as a temporary substitution? I feel like this will get the job done to an extent. im super excited all of a sudden xD |
|
|
|
|
yo vanilla
 MotoIQ Grease Monkey Send PM Posts:317
 Appleton, WI
 |
| 01-28-2011 03:55 AM |
|
For fun i just pulled the old June '08 SCC "greatest suspension test ever" issue off the shelf which compared different coilovers on S2000's. The two cheapest entries were Buddy Club and Tein Monoflex (each around $1700) with Tein garnering more praise between the two. I suppose you could find a used set of those in your price range Boxed Fox or anyone else, does nobody make a good standard spring anymore? Does NISMO offer anything on those lines for this car?
|
|
|
|
|
Mark_F
 MotoIQ Prodigy Send PM Posts:268

 |
| 01-28-2011 06:45 AM |
|
What about a spring and damper setup? Eibach or swift springs and bilstein shocks? Doesn't that setup account for daily driving with quality components and potential for track excursions? Potentially if you get good deals on the above, you could potentially score some sway bars to boot. |
|
|
|
|
speedball3
 MotoIQ Newb Send PM Posts:69

 |
| 01-28-2011 10:50 AM |
|
Yeah, I'm kind of surprised there aren't more calls for a decent damper and spring setup. Koni yellows, GC sleeves, and eibach springs were one of the most recommended setups when I was researching stuff for my Civic. Not everybody needs or can afford a full coilover setup.... and if the end performance goal is 95% street oriented, coilovers could be overkill. Plus, Koni (or whatever shock) + GC should be less than $1000. Even new shocks would probably make a noticable difference. |
|
|
|
|
Krash
 MotoIQ Newb Send PM Posts:6

 |
| 01-28-2011 10:53 AM |
|
Yea, i did some intese research. found some kts coils for 850. also found knoi dampers for 530 and Ground control for 2 something. so that might be my route as of now and later on if i still want coils find something then. as far as shocks i may keep those n change them to bilstein later when i find more money. |
|
|
|
|