You are here : Forum
MotoIQ Forums Minimize
Never Boost cuz your car will break!
Last Post 02-04-2012 05:43 PM by Coors75. 16 Replies.
Printer Friendly
Sort:
PrevPrev NextNext
You are not authorized to post a reply.
Author Messages
DaGouUser is Offline
MotoIQ Newb
MotoIQ Newb
Send PM
Posts:23
DaGou

--
01-30-2012 04:49 PM  
These are recent comments from the S2000 project car...What do you think?
 
# DaGou
Tuesday, January 17, 2012 11:14 PM
spdracerut, thanks for remembering I am a S2000 Turbo Fan. I can't beleive an application design engineer who eats sleeps and poops turbos would not want to design and apply the absolute most perfect turbo application for his car!?!?!?!?! Maybe you are just sick of turbo this turbo that all day long? If me and the rest of the turbo fans can't twist your arm and you do go NA (boring) you still have to design the perfect setup for everyone else! You probably already have it on paper. 

 
 
# DaGou
Tuesday, January 24, 2012 9:49 PM
Khiem, I was rereading the whole S2000 series again. A lot has changed for you in 2 years. Back then you stated:

Our goals for Project S2K are not as crazy as the usual MotoIQ fare. We are not out to build the baddest assed time attack car or build an unbalanced street terror. With project S2K, we are going for refined daily driver performance. We want to get the most from our S2000 but we do not want to give up OEM levels of drivability. We want something that we can drive to work every day, then drive to the track without a trailer, pound out some fast laps and drive home. We also don’t want something that screams give me a ticket to our local law enforcement agencies.

The big change is that car is no longer your daily driver. So are your goals still the same after two years? Even though everything was well planned would you do anything different? Happy with the 245's, need the added traction of 255's, 18" wheels for bigger big brakes? And as you know I hope you use your vast knowledge of turbo charging application engineering and not go NA. Really, an intake, an exhaust, new throttle body, intake manifold, and for what 50 HP. Rather see some cool small twin scroll super responsive turbo application. Anyway the big question is are you happy with everything and what are the new goals.
 
# spdracerut
Wednesday, January 25, 2012 1:53 AM
There's only one thing I'm going to revise and that's the front wheel spacers. The proper way to do it is to install longer wheel studs instead of the bolt-on spacer thing I used. The downside to installing longer studs is basically having to get new wheel bearings at the same time. Before, the KICS spacer allowed me to do what I needed to do easily and quickly. Now that I can put the car up on jack stands and not worry about having to drive to work the next day, I can do it the proper way.

Now that it's more of a fun car and not a DD, I'm going to tolerate a bit more NVH and noise. The motor mounts are shot so I'm thinking of putting in something a little stiffer. Maybe a mix of new stock mounts with one or two stiffer ones. I'm also thinking about intake, header and exhaust. A BIG maybe on the exhaust as I still want the car quiet. The intake will only be louder than stock when at WOT and the header won't add any more noticeable noise.

Additional safety items have already been planned. Overall, the car will become more driver focused, but still not extreme. It must still be streetable. Basically, think GT3RS, Z06, Cayman R, etc.

If the car were just for street duty, I'd turbo it in a heartbeat. But to make a car dead nuts reliable on the track for hours at a time is difficult at stock power levels and very difficult at double power levels. A turbo for sure would require track pads, even more oil cooling, and then you really have to start worrying about breaking the tranny and rear diff. Tranny and diff coolers would be good ideas too.

As the car sits, it's basically all the good stuff about the car amplified and it's actually a more comfortable DD due to the added chassis stiffness (no roof latch rattle) and better suspension. There are two major racing events I want to enter in the next year and a half, so that'll require some safety additions. Lots of small stuff to consider too as the stock parts wear out, like the rear diff mounts and control arm bushings. As they wear out, might as well upgrade.
 
# DaGou
Wednesday, January 25, 2012 2:39 PM
I have the upmost respect for you but Project S2000 is now about as exciting as Project Trailer...You do not want to build the car cuz it might break???? You want a track car to be dead nuts reliable??? Surprized you did not mention you wanted to get 40 miles to the gallon too. I guess I wish you did project S2000 10 or 15 years ago before you go to mature.
 
# Aaron LaBeau
Wednesday, January 25, 2012 4:08 PM
@DaGou - I've never driven a Porsche GT3 but I have driven a z06 and can totally understand the desire to build a powerful N/A track car. Always better to be racing than sitting in the pits with a busted car and have to drag it home on a trailer. To that point, it's always awesome to take a car to the track, race it all day and then drive it home. It's pretty nice when your car is setup to do all those things. The crazy exotic turbo stuff is fun also but when your at the limit parts break which gets expensive. Looks like Khiem prefers to keep racing all day. All that seat time seems like a pretty good idea to me.
 
# DaGou
Wednesday, January 25, 2012 7:33 PM
I am sure where ever you take it will be well done and I will continue to learn from you. Thanks for what you have done so far, you have taken me done a solid well thought out path. The project is tight, reliable and sticks to the road like glue, what more could you ask for.
 
# spdracerut
Thursday, January 26, 2012 1:15 AM
It would be more fun with a lot more power, but a conservative cost estimate to build a turbo the right along with the beefed up drivetrain is around $20k. More oil cooling, tranny and diff coolers, beefed up rear diff, stiffer mounts/bushings everywhere, lots of engine bay venting, making a bigger front opening to get more air into the engine bay/coolers, etc etc. One big issue is the smallish front opening on the S2k. Check out the front end of an Evo and it has a big opening just for the intercooler and then additional openings above that. A GTR has about double the front open area. More power = more heat to reject. So double the power = double the heat to reject. If someone wants to give me $20k
 
# DaGou
Monday, January 30, 2012 3:06 PM
Your automtive tunning knowledge dwarfs mine so much so that I am not even remotely qualified to disagree with anything you say. What you have said is that shelling out the five thousand or so for an average aftermarket kit for a turbo you need to put in another 15 thousand in parts to make the car worthy to carry the power. And even then cooling is an issue. All those companies out there making turbo and supercharges for the S2000 are just preying on a totally ignorant public. And those thousands of people who have boosted are riding time bombs(since few of them do the job right). I guess if I want a car that I can stay even with a run of the mill 5.0 Mustang I need to ditch this totally inadequate platform and find something else.
 
# phunky.buddha
Monday, January 30, 2012 3:19 PM
DaGou, the platform is still really good. If you want to keep up with a 5.0 on the street, it doesn't take much. If you want to beat on the S2k on the track all day long and not break stuff all the time, you'll have to spend the money reinforcing all the complementary systems along with the engine. The same goes for any street car honestly. There are very few street cars (especially in the S2k's price range) that will hold up well to constant track abuse, Mustang included. They all need some track prep if you're going to race them on a road course all the time.   
spdracerutUser is Offline
MotoIQ Engineer
MotoIQ Engineer
Send PM
Posts:613
spdracerut

--
01-30-2012 06:29 PM  

 Ha, I was about to reply in the comments   So here goes:

 

The only turbo kit that looks reasonable is the PTuning kit.  Throw in their oil cooler kit and cold air box, and it’s roughly $8500-$9000 after taxes.  Even then, I bet the oil temps are still pushing 270F+ in warmer weather which is too high for endurance work.  It’s okay for sprints, like 30 minute track sessions, but you just have to change the oil often and it will still reduce the life of the bearings.  Even then, I wouldn’t trust that manifold to not crack.  Forget about the Greddy kit, that manifold cracks just driving around on the street.  I helped a race team with their turbo kit (in preparation for the 25 hours of Thunderhill) and the only material that they could get to fabricate a manifold quickly was 304 stainless which pretty much what everyone makes their manifolds out of.  Though it was a simple log with extra beefiness, it eventually cracked after about 30 hours of use or so.  That included a 12 enduro test along with a few 3 hour races.  The replacement did last long enough to survive the 25 hours race.

So assuming the engine is good to go, the tranny and diff are definite weak points.  The auto-x guys are near stock power and generally bring a spare rear diff to Nationals competition because they tend to grenade when launching off the line with slicks.  Any turbo S2000 guy that drag races always has a spare diff ready to go to as it’s not a matter of if, but when even on street tires.  The Puddymod diff seems to be pretty strong and holds up to turbo abuse, but it is $3k.  There’s not too much that can be done in the tranny besides getting all the gears shot peened, etc.  But any time you put in twice the load that something was designed for, it’s going to fail much sooner.  Double the power also means double the heat, so tranny and diff coolers recommended. 

The only Mustang that seems to be track worthy is the Boss 302 Laguna Seca edition.  It comes with an oil cooler, baffled oil pan, an air scoop for the transmission, and a beefy Torsen rear diff.  It comes with the upgraded Brembo brakes, vented brake shields, brake ducts, and reinforced brake lines.  So Ford did basically everything I did to make a reliable track car that only has 7% more power (less peak torque though) than the regular GT.  Imagine what they’d have to do it make it reliable at double the power!

And at this winter track day, I was quite a bit faster than a brand new Mustang GT, though that may be due to driver ability.  I was also significantly quicker than a new, stock, Evo X on fresh tires though unknown on driver ability.  They’d both pull me on the straight pretty easily, but I’d eat them up in the corners.

There is one very very serious time attack S2000 build that is being shown in Modified.  He went with the Puddymod rear diff and made his own rear diff fluid cooler system.  He ditched the stock S2k tranny completely and went with a stronger, race purpose tranny.  He’s running an Accusump to prevent oil starvation and I think he’s going to be using an EFR8374.  So that’s a 700whp turbo (750whp pushed hard).  Lots of crazy body work and venting for heat management.  Of course, he has the benefit of being a purpose built race car so he can ditch things like the A/C condenser to improve cooling.

Well, point is, power = a lot more stress.  Also, it’s easy to make something last for 15-30 minute sprints.  Quite another to make it built proof over a 24 hours endurance event.  Fatigue life follows a logarithmic scale, so doubling stress reduces fatigue life by 1000x.  Which is why it is difficult to make a bulletproof track car.  A few years back in time attack, there was the Design Craft turbo S2000.  I think it spent roughly 10 hours getting fixed/wrenched on for every hour it was on track.  I felt bad for the mechanics as they always seemed to be working on the car at every event.

 

jereUser is Offline
MotoIQ Grease Monkey
MotoIQ Grease Monkey
Send PM
Posts:248
jere

--
01-30-2012 08:15 PM  
Wow 9K for a turbo kit?! I would be looking toward DIY for that money, and then maybe pick up a back up car with some money left over. Seriously 20k for upgrades, is a little high don't you think? Or are you paying someone else to install all the parts or something?
spdracerutUser is Offline
MotoIQ Engineer
MotoIQ Engineer
Send PM
Posts:613
spdracerut

--
01-30-2012 11:06 PM  
Posted By jere on 01-30-2012 10:15 PM
Wow 9K for a turbo kit?! I would be looking toward DIY for that money, and then maybe pick up a back up car with some money left over. Seriously 20k for upgrades, is a little high don't you think? Or are you paying someone else to install all the parts or something?


That's doing all the work yourself.  Going fast AND not breaking ain't cheap!  There's a reason why the new turn-key racecar Ford Focus ST cost $100k.  Personally, I don't think the PTuning manifold will hold up to extreme use, i,e real racing and not just a track day. Though I suppose, it could just be considered a wear item and just get it rewelded or have a spare laying around.

Back to the S2k.  PTuning kit is roughly $9k in cost alone, not installed.  Add in an exhaust, $1k.  I personally think it needs a bigger oil cooler.  Add in tranny and rear diff oil coolers.  Roughly $1500 for the heat exchangers, lines, pumps, fittings, brackets, etc.  Puddymod rear diff, $3k.  Vented hood.... there are a few different ways to go about it.  Let's say DIY so it's free except for your own time.  Or a cheap one for $700 if you don't care about the quality of it.  The front openings really need to be opened up, but some custom work with a sawzall can take care of that, freebie.  A set of stiffer motor mounts to handle the greater torque, $350.  Ideally, get the gears in the transmission micropolished and shotpeened, but we'll skip that.  Oh yeah, radiator, $350 for a Koyo.

Not including labor, we're past $15k already.  Oh yeah, forgot about the clutch, $550.  HASPORT rear diff mounts, $300.  I think you can put in the OS Giken diff with the Puddymod beefed up rear diff, so you can tack on another $1600 if you want, though I think the money would be better spent taking the tranny apart and strengthening the gears.

jereUser is Offline
MotoIQ Grease Monkey
MotoIQ Grease Monkey
Send PM
Posts:248
jere

--
01-31-2012 07:25 AM  
I see your point, and that really makes me appreciate having a cheap car to mess with.
speedball3User is Offline
MotoIQ Newb
MotoIQ Newb
Send PM
Posts:69
speedball3

--
02-01-2012 11:48 AM  

Building a mixed street/track car for a 25hr race is a bit overkill, but since the idea is a pain-free fun track day car, I suppose it makes sense. At the same time, it is understandable that since you have already improved the car's strengths that you wouldn't want to mess too much with a well balanced package.  Plus, keeping it NA seems closer to the original S2K concept.

Thinking out loud...has the rotrex supercharger idea been thrown around before?  That might let you bypass the cracking turbo manifold issue, though the extra stress on transmission/rear diff doesn't go away.

Off topic, but I remember an article where Mike said the Cooper S is a great track-ready car out of the box. It'd be interesting to see a MotoIQ Project Cooper S for the purpose of taking a detailed look at just how well equipped a stock or near stock Cooper S is at surviving a 25hr race (or at least meeting that goal based on track test results, like the Project S2k has been subjected to).

smartbombUser is Offline
MotoIQ Super Genius
MotoIQ Super Genius
Send PM
Posts:1904
Mike Kojima

--
02-01-2012 01:26 PM  
If you could get rid of that cars multi stupid electronic nannies.
spdracerutUser is Offline
MotoIQ Engineer
MotoIQ Engineer
Send PM
Posts:613
spdracerut

--
02-01-2012 06:26 PM  

 Ironically, someone started a thread on s2ki.com about how much money they've spent:

http://www.s2ki.com/s2000/topic/926...you-spent/

I'll quote a few:

"Other then coilovers, wheels/tires, I have always looked for deals on used stuff to help save money, but after owning the car for 7 years and putting about 200k on it during that time. I have spent an easy $25k in upgraded performance parts, two replacement motors, two trans and three rear ends."

 

"I'm right at $15k for my turbo kit setup with fuel system. This includes tunes, clutch, labor, AEM EMS with gauges, powdercoating, exhaust fab., etc  Boost is expensive! "

 

"Well I actually log every purchase and every hour spent so that I can accurately show people how long and expensive it really is. Not including the car the Greddy build was right at $12K including clutch wheels, tires..... at the end of the IP build I was sitting at $25.5K and by the time I sold the car with the Mase Kit I was up to $36K. Total was about 107 line items ranging from oil to complete turbo kit. Take out the sale of the all the parts and the net loss was around $10-12K. Then you figure in the time and at my billable rate of $60/hour well, let’s just say it was a BIG NUMBER. 

Flash forward to my current build, I have learned a lot of lessons and now know the trusted vendors, what I like and want and what works. I figure I can build a reliable turbo setup able to take to HPDE days, shows and drive around town laying down 550ish WHP on a budget of $23K not including the car with about 150 hours invested. As it stands I have spent $13K and 3 hours but the car is stock with exception to SOS hood struts and being pretty clean. The final trick is the sale of the parts and I am shooting for a net loss of only $5K if I sell within 1-2 years.

To be honest I don't think I will hit my budget but I am looking for deals and taking my time. I have 10K for the turbo kit but that includes dual 340lph pumps, ID1000's, Fuel rail, Haltech, Flexfuel sensor, radiator, boost modulated cutout, powder coating, ATP heat shielding, oil cooler, cams, valve springs, MAP, boost solenoid, pulgs, hoses........Add it all up and the number is a bit light. 

Complete Turbo Kit w/ Fuel Management...........$10,000
Clutch..........................................$700
Wheels and Tires................................$2,700
Hardtop.........................................$2,500
Brakes..........................................$2,700
Suspension......................................$2,000
Paint & Body Work...............................$1,000
Misc Interior and Accessories...................$1,000
Differential w/ LSD.............................$3,000
=======================================================
Total...........................................$23,600 "

M-PUser is Offline
MotoIQ ASE Certified
MotoIQ ASE Certified
Send PM
Posts:124
M-P

--
02-01-2012 07:38 PM  
Boost is quite expensive, but what "Differential w/ LSD" is $3000? Seems like that guy paid someone WAY too much.

To the purpose of this thread....who cares if he wants to turbo the car or not? I love turbos too and if it were my car it would probably get a turbo, but to each their own. You don't have to turbocharge everything under the sun in order to make it a good project car, good track car, good street car, etc.
M-PUser is Offline
MotoIQ ASE Certified
MotoIQ ASE Certified
Send PM
Posts:124
M-P

--
02-01-2012 07:38 PM  
Boost is quite expensive, but what "Differential w/ LSD" is $3000? Seems like that guy paid someone WAY too much.

To the purpose of this thread....who cares if he wants to turbo the car or not? I love turbos too and if it were my car it would probably get a turbo, but to each their own. You don't have to turbocharge everything under the sun in order to make it a good project car, good track car, good street car, etc.
spdracerutUser is Offline
MotoIQ Engineer
MotoIQ Engineer
Send PM
Posts:613
spdracerut

--
02-01-2012 10:10 PM  
Posted By M-P on 02-01-2012 09:38 PM
Boost is quite expensive, but what "Differential w/ LSD" is $3000? Seems like that guy paid someone WAY too much.


The Puddymod rear diff is $3k.  It's a super fortified S2k diff that's much much stronger than the stock unit.  It's the only one to get if you have a boosted S2k as everything else will break.

There's a big difference between boosting a car that's a DD and gets beat on once in a while for HPDE (been there, done that) as compared to a car that's meant to be beat on mercilessly.  My old Nissan SE-R, I boosted that and made more than double the stock HP for 80k miles.  I tracked it once in a while and auto-x'd it quite a bit.  However, I always had a keen eye on the water temp gauge, I faded the brakes a few times on a road course, and I never used 3rd gear on the street for fear of grenading it (see Project G20 racecar at Las Vegas MPTCC).  I picked up a G35 sedan for a DD and I would have no issues at all boosting that as it's just a DD; it won't see much stress at all.  Like I said, someone give me $20k and I'll make a reliable boosted S2k that can be beat on mercilessly 

M-PUser is Offline
MotoIQ ASE Certified
MotoIQ ASE Certified
Send PM
Posts:124
M-P

--
02-02-2012 07:56 AM  
Posted By spdracerut on 02-02-2012 12:10 AM
Posted By M-P on 02-01-2012 09:38 PM
Boost is quite expensive, but what "Differential w/ LSD" is $3000? Seems like that guy paid someone WAY too much.


The Puddymod rear diff is $3k.  It's a super fortified S2k diff that's much much stronger than the stock unit.  It's the only one to get if you have a boosted S2k as everything else will break.

Crazy...was not aware of that.

smartbombUser is Offline
MotoIQ Super Genius
MotoIQ Super Genius
Send PM
Posts:1904
Mike Kojima

--
02-02-2012 08:16 AM  
I know Steff Papadakis converted his drift S2K to a Nissan R200 diff to solve the weak diff issues.
spdracerutUser is Offline
MotoIQ Engineer
MotoIQ Engineer
Send PM
Posts:613
spdracerut

--
02-02-2012 09:10 AM  
Posted By Mike Kojima on 02-02-2012 10:16 AM
I know Steff Papadakis converted his drift S2K to a Nissan R200 diff to solve the weak diff issues.

InlinePro makes a R200 diff install kit for $3600.  Does NOT include diff.

http://www.inlinepro.com/s1/p-31-s2000-diff-kit.aspx

I'm weary of it though..... I figure the less I mess with the OEM setup, the better as I don't know the level of engineering that went into the kit.

M-PUser is Offline
MotoIQ ASE Certified
MotoIQ ASE Certified
Send PM
Posts:124
M-P

--
02-02-2012 06:38 PM  
It seems like they dumped ALOT of aluminum into that kit and that is probably where most of the cost comes from. I have to imagine there was a less expensive (albeit less bling) way of doing that.
smartbombUser is Offline
MotoIQ Super Genius
MotoIQ Super Genius
Send PM
Posts:1904
Mike Kojima

--
02-03-2012 08:48 PM  
Wow no kidding.
Coors75User is Offline
MotoIQ Newb
MotoIQ Newb
Send PM
Posts:26
Corey

--
02-04-2012 05:43 PM  

I know there is at least one British tuner that has been using the (r200) 300zx diff on their supercharged s2000 running 600ish whp. Though I don't think the kits where very cheap. I will and try and find the article about it if I can as I think they were one of the first to do it.

In terms of DD vs boosted track machine I think it is hard for us without the experience to imagine the stress and issues involved in running a competitive boosted racecar and think "well it can';t be that much more difficult". Though it is my understanding that many of the big NA machines (ie. LS series ) have heating issues as well.

I suspect the s2000 has handling that can make it a great hpde car without the risks involved in turocharging.

You are not authorized to post a reply.

Active Forums 4.1


Copyright 2012 by MotoIQ.com
Privacy Statement Terms Of Use Advertise